The AV Club
I hit a point a couple of years ago where I started to feel over saturated with entertainment media. I got fed up reading reviews and articles and just kind of stopped seeking it all out. The one exception was the AV Club, which provides consistently insightful and compelling commentary on all manners of entertainment.
Their opinions almost always mirror my own pretty much exactly. I got more star struck visiting their offices and meeting my favourite writers than I get meeting most musicians I admire.